Changes between Version 16 and Version 17 of u/GasPhiBE


Ignore:
Timestamp:
10/04/12 13:57:37 (12 years ago)
Author:
Erica Kaminski
Comment:

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • u/GasPhiBE

    v16 v17  
    9898==== Matched Case ====
    9999
     100From my sim:
     101
    100102[[Image(MatchedPhi.png, 60%)]]
    101 [[Image(LineMatchedPhi.png, 60%]]
    102103
     104[[Image(LineMatchedPhi.png, 50%)]]
    103105
     106Here is the function of phi as found above:
     107
     108[[Image(MatchedMMa.png, 60%)]].
     109
     110Now, this is where things get hard for me to understand. First, I see the range of phi, and magnitude of phi is drastically different for this matched ambient case. This may make sense, based on more mass in the ambient meaning stronger gravitational potential due to the ambient. However, I would expect that at very small radii, just above Rbe, the approximation of the ambient as a uniform sphere should be very good. This is because there is SOOOO much more mass in the ambient than in the sphere (see above calculation). Thus, very early on, I would expect the potential to be growing more and more negative as more and more mass is enclosed in this uniform sphere. Indeed, we see this behavior from the function derived above, but NOT in the simulation. Can someone please explain this discrepancy?